Share with:

Creativity Online

Tony Granger's ANDY Diary, Part 3

Young & Rubicam's worldwide CD Tony Granger is judging the ANDYs on the Mayan Riviera; here are his closing thoughts about the time spent in Mexico.

By: Tony Granger, Published: Feb 25, 2009
We ended a day early, which gave us the opportunity to explore the Mayan Riviera. I haven't ever seen beaches that are quite as white or water that is quite as blue. And when you get out of the rows and rows of resorts catering to the American tourist, you can actually still feel the presence of the Mayan culture that ruled here for so long. But enough of the travelogue--back to the work.

Our last day of judging was the most intense.

The print/outdoor gold, silver and bronzes were laid on tables, and Mark took us through every piece one at a time, confirming with a show of hands whether a piece deserved a gong or not. The print is so thin this year, if you have won any gong in this medium, no matter what color, you should feel very proud. Slim pickings indeed.

Then over to film, digital and integrated. Again we reviewed each piece with a show of hands. I have been sworn to secrecy, but I am convinced that when you see the work this fine bunch of creatives have chosen, you'll be inspired. I know I am. I can't wait to go back to New York and share the learning and apply it to our work.

Inspirational stuff. With one exception. Radio. Not one winner. Not even a finalist. That's really sad actually. Where are the beautifully written spots that use theater of the mind to make you laugh or cry? Anyone wanting to go for easy pickings next year. Radio.

Gone are the days when one piece of work no matter how brilliant will win a GRANDY. The idea has to be larger than one execution. It has to be an idea that touches many media channels and that create a stir online and off line. And when you think about it, that's what most clients want anyway.

In my mind, we're in the most exciting time in our business in a very long time. Sure money is tight. Sure business is tough. But what is exciting is that these times present an exciting opportunity for our industry to reinvent itself. And the GRANDY this year is proof that we are indeed evolving.



Young & Rubicam's worldwide CD Tony Granger is judging the ANDYs on the Mayan Riviera; he'll provide a view from the judges' perspective throughout the week. Read his previous installments here and here. Our previous special correspondent, Andrew Keller, wrote us diaries from Buenos Aires and Sydney.
2 Comments: By jeaker February 25th, 2009 08:12:51 pm

This is lame. Diary entries from the Mayan Riviera while judging an awards show? L.-A-M-E. Look, we all know there are perks in this business. You don't need to rub them in our faces. But really... the world economy is falling apart, layoffs in our industry are at an all time high and the lucky few of us who still have our jobs are being stretched thinner than ever. And you think we want to hear Tony Granger talk about the Mayan Riviera. Jeez. How many people did Tony layoff this year? Mayan Riviera? Christ man, wake up.

By andrejdwin February 27th, 2009 04:28:32 am

radio has never been strong as far as my memory goes.
never.
and especially at international shows.
of course, one part of it is that the medium is neglected by everyone. second part of the problem is that radio, unlike any other media, has only one strong tool and one very weak tool to work with (text and sfx) as opposed to all other media working with a combination of at least two strong tools (visual/text).
but given that the "weak radio category" is seen mostly in the international shows, let's admit the problem lies in the fact that you can't translate every good radio idea into English in a way that a crowd of international judges would get its beauty.
and this, ladies and gentlemen, is the state of the thing.

Email a friend